For this album, Grohl brought together Pat Smear on guitar and Nate Mendel on bass. The lyrics of The Colour and the Shape reflect an intense personal moment for Grohl, marked by a sentimental breakup. This introspection is reflected in the compositions, seeking a balance between the energy of the more upbeat songs and the depth of the ballads, as if it were a journey through mixed emotions. From this work emerged songs that are fundamental today, such as My Hero, Monkey Wrench, and, of course, Everlong, which became one of the group's most recognized songs. The album had a good reception, reaching third place on the UK charts and tenth in the United States.
This album was nominated in 1998 for a Grammy Award in the category of Best Rock Album. Until 2005, it remained Foo Fighters' best-selling album in the United States. Ten years after its original release, in 2007, a special edition was released that included additional material, celebrating a decade of this work. The composition of all the songs is attributed to Dave Grohl, Nate Mendel, and Pat Smear.