The album resonated strongly, reaching number 6 on the Billboard 200 and earning triple platinum certification. Songs like If It Makes You Happy and A Change Would Do You Good became hits, showcasing a more confident voice and polished production. Critics praised the album’s depth, and Sheryl Crow won the Grammy Award for Best Rock Album, while If It Makes You Happy earned Crow the Grammy for Best Female Rock Vocal Performance. The track Love Is a Good Thing, with its critique of gun sales, even prompted Walmart to ban the album from its stores, a notable departure from her earlier work.
Beyond the well-known hits, the album includes gems like Redemption Day and Every Day Is a Winding Road, which later featured in the soundtrack of the 2000 film *Erin Brockovich*. This record demonstrated Crow’s ability to craft music that, while accessible, also tackled complex themes and showcased a broader sonic palette, incorporating instruments like the banjo and steel guitar, and sometimes more elaborate rhythms.